Wota Want To Be Kanna, Or: Possibly TMI Fun In Relation To Kid Idols
May 9, 2008
Times like these that I wonder why I get so involved in… I don’t know, like, the lives, the well-being of the girls in Hello! Project. I’m telling you, it’s difficult! It is really, really hard. You know, all of my favorite idols usually end up being terribly handicapped in some way, or they have some awful problem, or just… whatever. I always pick the lamest ones.
Just for comparison’s sake, let’s look at what might be considered the more “perfect” girls in Hello! Project. Here’s an easy one… Sugaya Risako. Sure, she can’t sing, she’s got attitude problems like nobody’s business, but these things are all very easily overlooked because she’s fourteen years old and she’s jailbait city. I mean, right? She’s a lead. No problems there. Um, how about another one? Kago Ai, golden girl from the very beginning. Sure, you say you feel so horribly betrayed by her when she smokes or gets it on with old men, but then she comes back and you’re right back at her feet again. Don’t lie.
Now let’s look at my favorites. In her history, Michishige Sayumi has accidentally thrown a microphone, leaving her with no choice but to mime her way through the rest of a live television performance. Ishimura Maiha could not dance for shit. While she is not related to Hello! Project at all, Matsushima Hatsune is the kind of girl you’d laugh at and trip in the halls if she didn’t have some pretty amazing knockers to her name. I’m sorry, I just don’t know what to say. All I can tell you is the truth.
This has created a pretty bad habit of… I guess you’d call it “mothering from afar.” And a majority of these girls are either older than me or nearly my age, but I just can’t help it. They need help. To my credit? This is usually, for the most part, a joke. I feel the “aww” reaction, but I do not act upon it… because I’m in the fucking United States.
However. (And this is the first of many times that I’ll say it, but this is the hardest thing…) This is the first time that I have, for real, felt that mothering instinct in full force. Like, “Bitches, get out of my way! Move, motherfucker! My baby needs me!” It is seriously hard.

Oh, Kanna. You’re breaking my heart.
I think — well, I assume — that most people have at least heard of the Whoa, Kanna Is A Lesbian! rumor? Months ago, I caught wind of it, but as they were just the words of some random person referencing it offhand, I was pretty much like “Yeah, okay” and then I went back to writing my Yajima Maimi/Umeda Erika fanfiction. (…That one wasn’t so much of a joke, by the way. I can seriously link you if you want it.) Without the evidence or a source to back it up, I wasn’t really interested.
Fast forward to a couple of days ago. If you’ve ever been near YouTube, you know that one video leads to another, which leads to another, which leads to another, until you have no idea what you were even looking at to begin with. Yeah, that’s how I found this. Suddenly, it all came rushing back: “Oh, right, I remember that!” Finally, I had the original source of it all to come to my own conclusions about it. And wow, what a controversial clip it is.

First of all, the reactions in the video’s comments are not at all favorable, as is to be expected. “Such a pretty girl, why choose gay” is far and away my favorite of the bunch. But there’s also, more than anything, in fact, a whole lot of denial. “She can’t mean that,” they say. “She has to be meaning something else. This isn’t true.”
I’m not even going to try to say something like, “Well, is it?! We’ll find out when I put my rudimentary Japanese skills to the test!!” I think, when you try to force what you think are the facts out of an inconsequential, fifty-second radio show clip like that, you miss the point entirely. Point? Sure, she may or may not be into girls, but isn’t it… kind of cruel to say things that indicate that you’d pretty much drop her ass like a hot potato if she were? No matter what the outcome, that shines right through.


Then again, ℃-ute themselves aren’t much support, either. All those cries of “Eeeeeeehhh?!” would put me right off of just casually being like, “No, I’m seriously into pussy.” God, what a situation.
If I’m hearing correctly in the video, someone whose voice I can’t quite place mentions a Fujimoto, but I could be wrong… In any case, that bit of name-dropping comes in when they’re elaborating on why Kanna could feel the way that she does: “Perhaps you prefer being around your female friends as opposed to boys?” Miki had an almost identical moment on a radio show, as well, so I wouldn’t be surprised if she was brought into the conversation as an example. Thing is, Miki was at least twenty at the time, and Kanna’s, what, fourteen?
So, as you see, we’re coming back to where I started now. Poor thing is so young, and to boot, she’s an only child! Sheesh, Sayu’s had too many lesbian moments to count, but at least she could call up her beloved older sister for advice. “Oneechan, lately I’ve been groping my friends in concerts. Do you think I like girls?” It’s almost tragically hopeless.

And I know, at the source of it all, that I can trace it back to my similar experiences in childhood. Sigh. Kanna’s almost an exact replica of me as a kid, which makes it all the more painful to watch. The only person I had to talk to about the situation was my mother, who, after I finally got up the courage to bring it up to her, brushed it off and wouldn’t discuss it with me further without rolling her eyes and generally giving off the impression that she thought me immature. I was maybe thirteen at the time, and now I’m going on seventeen. Amazing! My feelings haven’t changed. Understandably, I want nothing more than to give her a hug and assure her that a kind gaijin is there for her should she need to talk! Sure, maybe that’s creepy, but I have the best of intentions!
Eh, but Kanna’s also young, and for Christ’s sake, she’s surrounded by like forty chicks in a world where she’s strictly prohibited from dating guys. That must be hard for a maturing girl, huh? Sometimes I wonder if Hello! Project is really the greatest thing to be a part of… The Kids, especially, I wish could grow up normally. Anyway, altogether, this ends up kind of inconclusive and maybe a waste of some thirteen hundred words, but hey, who said I was ever looking for a conclusion, anyway? Mostly I just wanted to find a way to express my thoughts on the weird sort of phobia that the Hello! Project fandom has towards these things. Ever gradually, I come closer to that ideal of actually relating to the shit I write about on my blog…
Whatever her situation, I really wish Kanna the best, along with all the time and understanding in the world to sort out her feelings. She’s inspired me — that’s got to count for something, anyway. And as far as I’m concerned? The wota are just jealous because she’s getting more delicious Airi goodness than they’ll ever even be anywhere close to. Just gotta brush off the haters, ROFL.
May 11, 2008 at 5:46 am
A lot of homophobics are in denial about homophobia, it seems.
It’s depressing that some people seem to be somewhat disgusted by her supposed sexuality.
May 11, 2008 at 5:44 pm
wow, nice article
i recently started getting into c-ute. and kanna was one of the first i saw (besides the original that i remember, umeda). hmm interesting, interesting.
May 11, 2008 at 6:50 pm
I’ve started to admire Kanna more since I heard about the possibility of she being lesbian. She’s someone I can identify with.
Love, Charmy
May 11, 2008 at 9:07 pm
Oh, good, I’m glad for all the positive comments. 8D; After I posted this I kind of thought, “Shit, there goes my credibility, huh?”
KANNA. Kanna is like my little sister and I beat up people who say bad things about her, rofl.
May 11, 2008 at 9:42 pm
Geez. Do people seriously say that? Girls her age ususally DO perfer hanging around other girls. Boys still have cooties. And if they don’t, girls just think its too awkward being around them at that age. And for the past five years, the only testosterone she’s seen is Tsunku’s and any male family she has. So naturally she’d perfer hanging around girls to guys.
It does not mean she’s gay. >.>
May 12, 2008 at 3:51 pm
I love lesbo-Kanna even if she’ll never love me back due to age, geography and sexual orientation. That’s all I’ve got to say.
May 14, 2008 at 12:21 am
Her comment doesn’t sound very controversial to me. I didn’t even realise the existence of guys for a long time… Anyhow, I like Kanna loads.
May 15, 2008 at 12:59 am
Excellent post, Vulpi. I too am disappointed, to say the least, in this attitude of willful ignorance that’s present in much of the population. A lot of people claim to be fine with orientations other than their own, only to react with disgust at the possibility that someone they respect might actually not have the orientation they were pre-supposed to have. Being genderqueer and asexual, I’ve had my share of the assumed-heteronormativity/cisnormativity thinking of much of the population, somewhat complicated by the fact that both my gender identity and sexual orientation are unknown to most of the population (on the positive side, I guess there are fewer assumptions for people to make when they find out I’m genderqueer and asexual…).
It’d be nice if everyone realized that sexual orientation and gender identity were properties ranging over a continuous set of values rather than a small set of distinct values (straight/gay/bi, cis/trans, male/female), but I’ve gotten a sense that most people like having little boxes that they can make sure everyone else fits into nicely, and then get upset when they found out someone they put in one box actually should be in the other, or even worse, doesn’t fit in any of the boxes they’ve constructed.
This is one of the downsides to H!P’s rule against dating. On the one hand, it preserves the ambiguity and makes it easier for idols to be themselves without putting themselves in one of these boxes by making it known that they’re dating someone (which in the minds of many people settles the issue as to whether someone is in the “straight” box or the “gay” box … other orientations notwithstanding), and I imagine it’s less stressful for asexual idols who aren’t into dating, because then there’s no pressure to date (I can tell you I’ve had my own share of pressure to date, from people who didn’t understand aromantic asexuality). On the other hand, this makes it a lot easier for fans to make their own assumptions (that every idol is “normal” … whatever that might mean). Statistically, there are going to be some idols who don’t fit what their fans expect them to be. Is it better to encourage that illusion or be more open about the orientations of idols? It’s a difficult issue with problems on all sides.
Anyway, I’ve been ranting for long enough. But the issue of sexuality/gender identity with respect to idols is an interesting one that I plan to write about sometime.
September 24, 2008 at 1:27 pm
[...] have to bring up a dated entry by Vulpi at DEKOBOKO17, one where she talks about the Arihara Kanna lesbian rumors in here. The [...]
February 25, 2009 at 2:52 am
i doesn’t matter if your gay or lesbian,it matters if your happy
June 4, 2011 at 9:06 am
[...] have to bring up a dated entry by Vulpi at DEKOBOKO17, one where she talks about the Arihara Kanna lesbian rumors in here. The [...]